Opens in a new tab
A black and white photo of the NYC skyline
Rated 5.0 on Avvo

NYC Mechanics' Liens Attorney

Superior Skill, Superior Work Ethic, Superior Results

Mechanic’s lien disputes can create problems for contractors seeking payment and property owners trying to sell, refinance, or move forward with a project. New York has many requirements for filing, enforcing, and challenging mechanic’s liens, and missing a deadline or making a filing error can affect your legal options.

Led by attorney Scott Richman, we represent contractors, builders, suppliers, and property owners in mechanic’s lien matters in New York City.

Whether you need to secure payment for completed work or challenge a lien filed against your property, our firm can help you understand your rights and determine the best plan. We represent clients on both sides of mechanic’s lien disputes, bringing experience in preparing, enforcing, and contesting liens under New York law. Contact us today for a free consultation.

How Mechanics’ Liens Work

A mechanic’s lien can come from general contractors, subcontractors, or suppliers who performed work or delivered materials and weren’t paid. Whether their contract was with the owner or with the contractor above them, the lien attaches to the property’s title, so the owner may have trouble selling or refinancing until the debt is settled.

When the Clock Starts

A contractor or supplier has 8 months from the last day of work or the last delivery of materials to file a lien, or 4 months when the work is on a single-family home. A lien filed after the window closes may be invalid, regardless of the invoice date. Filing the lien while the payment talks continue keeps the claim alive.

On a public project, a subcontractor or supplier may file a written demand to be told when the public owner completes and accepts the work, so the sub or supplier knows when the deadline clock starts. Property owners, general contractors, and material suppliers who aren’t sure when the clock started should talk with a construction law attorney.

Filing and Enforcing Mechanics’ Liens in New York

Notice of Mechanic’s Lien

Mechanics’ liens start when a contractor or similar files a notice with the county clerk in the county where the property is located.

The notice describes names, the property, labor or materials and their agreed price or value, and states the amount unpaid and the dates of the first and last work.

Enforcing a Lien

A lienor collects through a foreclosure action, in which the court can order the property sold and apply the proceeds to the debt. The lien lasts 1 year from the filing date. To keep it alive, the lienor has to start the foreclosure and file a notice of pendency within that year, or extend the lien.

Satisfaction of Mechanics’ Liens

When a mechanic’s lien is paid in full, it’s discharged by filing a satisfaction of lien with the county clerk, which takes it off the title so the property owner can go ahead with pending transactions. If the party who filed the lien refuses or fails to file a satisfaction of lien after the debt is paid, they may be liable for damages.

Removing Mechanics’ Liens

Removing a mechanic’s lien from a property clears the title so a sale or refinance can go forward.

  • Payment in Full: The easiest way to remove a mechanic’s lien is to pay the debt in full, usually in exchange for a lien waiver.
  • Depositing the Amount Claimed: Before a foreclosure starts, an owner may discharge a lien by depositing the amount claimed, plus interest, with the county clerk. The deposit then stands in for the property while the dispute is resolved.
  • Contesting the Lien: If the lien was filed late, is missing required information, or claims work that can’t support a lien, you may petition the court to discharge it summarily. The court decides disputes over the quality of the work or the amount owed in the foreclosure action. An owner may serve a notice requiring the lienor to start the foreclosure within a set time, at least 30 days after service, or explain to the court why the lien should stand.
  • Bonding off the Lien: The owner or the contractor may discharge a lien by filing a surety bond for 110% of the lien amount with the county clerk and serving it on the lienor. The bond replaces the property as security for the debt while the property owner disputes the lien’s validity.

Legal Solutions for All Parties in Construction

Builders and Contractors

If a general contractor isn’t paid, they still owe subcontractors and suppliers on the job, and each of them may file a lien against the same project. Difficulty getting paid by the owner quickly becomes the GC’s problem with payroll, operating costs, and the next project.

We file the GC’s lien correctly and on time under New York Lien Law, and we look at the GC’s exposure to liens filed by the subs and suppliers below it.

Suppliers

Suppliers often face delayed payments for materials they’ve already delivered to a project, and the gap shows up in their cash flow and in how much work they can take on. We help suppliers file and enforce mechanics’ liens to get paid for what they provided.

Property Owners

An owner who has already paid the general contractor in full can still receive a lien from a subcontractor or supplier the owner never dealt with. The owner’s exposure depends on how much was still unpaid on the contract when the lien was filed, and we check the unpaid balance first.

A lien can also stall or stop a project, and a foreclosure can force the sale of the property. We dispute claimed amounts, question whether the work was finished, and challenge the lien’s validity in mediation or, when needed, in litigation.

Contact Us for a Free Consultation

A mechanic’s lien runs on deadlines that leave little room to fix a mistake. A contractor who files a month late, describes the property wrong, or misses the 35-day window to file proof of service can lose the lien and, with it, the property as security for the debt.

For a property owner, a lien on the title stalls a sale or a refinance until it is paid, bonded, or removed by a court, and it can stay there for a year or longer while the contractor decides whether to sue.

Our attorneys prepare, file, and serve liens for contractors, subcontractors, and suppliers, and we check every lien served against the deadlines and the amount owed. Contact us for a free consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a subcontractor file a lien if the property owner hasn’t paid the general contractor?

Yes. A subcontractor or supplier hired by the general contractor may file a lien directly against the property. The lien is limited to the amount still unpaid on the owner’s contract with the general contractor when the lien is filed. If an owner is holding back payment from the general contractor, the owner still owes it, and the subcontractor may enforce the lien for as much as the owner still owes on the contract.

Do I have to notify the property owner after filing a mechanic’s lien?

Yes. You must serve a copy of the notice of lien on the property owner within 5 days before or 30 days after filing it. You must then file proof of service with the county clerk within 35 days of filing, or the lien terminates.

Can I still sell or refinance my property while a mechanic’s lien is on it?

Yes. A bond takes the lien off the title so the sale or refinance can close. The owner or the general contractor may file a bond for 110% of the lien amount with the county clerk, and the contractor’s claim then runs against the bond while the dispute over what is owed continues after the closing.

Can a lien be filed even if the property owner claims the work was bad?

Yes. A contractor or subcontractor may file a lien for services or materials provided under a valid contract while the quality of the work is still in dispute. The owner can then challenge the lien in court, arguing that defective work reduces what is owed or that the lien overstates the amount.

What happens if a contractor files a lien for more than I owe?

If the court finds at the trial of the foreclosure action that a lien was exaggerated, the lien is void, and the person who filed it may owe the property owner damages. Those damages may include the premium paid for a bond to discharge the lien, reasonable attorney’s fees for removing it, and the difference between the amount claimed and the amount owed. To prove willful exaggeration, an owner generally needs evidence that the contractor knew the amount was inflated.

What happens if a mechanic’s lien is not filed in time?

A court may declare a late lien invalid under New York Lien Law, leaving the contractor or lienholder unable to collect what’s owed. A property owner facing a lien that county records show was filed after the deadline may ask a court to discharge it without waiting for the contractor to sue. Because the statutory requirements are strict, working with an attorney before the deadline gives a contractor the best chance of filing a lien that can be enforced.

Schedule a Free Consultation

Primary Contact Form
SCOTT B. RICHMAN, ESQ.

Managing Member & Founder

5.0
on Avvo

Mr. Richman is the Managing Member and Founder of Richman Law Firm PLLC. In his role as Managing Member, Mr. Richman oversees the day-to-day operations of the firm and handles the litigation of the most complex legal matters across a vast array of practice areas and disciplines.

Read What Our Clients Say About Us

Client Testimonials

    Scott Richman was hands down the best attorney we have ever had. He helped our company solve a tricky and challenging problem with speed, efficiency and professionalism. His knowledge and attention to detail go well beyond this 5 star rating. He is exceptional at what he does and I would highly recommend him.

    Scott of Richman Law is fantastic. Communicative, diligent, and reliable. He went above and beyond to ensure we not only received what we deserved, but more. If you’re looking for a fantastic lawyer, you’ve found one in Scott!

    Scott is a phenomenal lawyer. He came through for us when we were in desperate need of help. Scott always got back to us quickly for any questions we had. Highly recommend and would no doubt use his services again if needed.

    Scott proved to be an exceptional attorney, navigating my case with remarkable swiftness and unwavering diligence. In addition, Danielle exuded both warmth and professionalism, further enhancing my overall experience. I wholeheartedly recommend.