A black and white photo of the NYC skyline
Rated 5.0 on Avvo

NYC Undisclosed Property Defects Attorney

Superior Skill, Superior Work Ethic, Superior Results

The joy of purchasing a new property can quickly become a headache when undisclosed defects come up after the transaction.  When undisclosed defects are discovered, buyers have the right to seek legal remedies to address these issues and recover losses incurred. This is where Richman Law Firm PLLC steps in.

Our experience in real estate litigation is an asset when it’s time to seek compensation for losses incurred due to undisclosed defects. Reach out to Richman Law Firm PLLC today for a free consultation.

Caveat Emptor (Buyer Beware)

Caveat Emptor is a Latin term meaning “Buyer Beware”. It is a traditional legal rule that places the onus on the buyer to ensure the quality and suitability of a property before purchase.

However, various consumer protection laws have significantly modified Caveat Emptor in today’s real estate market. While it is still key for buyers to conduct due diligence, sellers and agents also have legal obligations to disclose known defects.

Buyer’s Due Diligence and Why It Is Important

In real estate transactions, due diligence refers to the process where the buyer carefully investigates the details of a property before finalizing the deal. It is a very important step that can help avoid potential legal and financial pitfalls down the line.

This process includes verifying the information provided by the seller, inspecting the property for defects, checking for legal issues, and assessing the property’s value. A buyer’s due diligence may involve hiring professionals such as property inspectors, appraisers, and attorneys to examine all aspects of the property and contract drafts.

Due diligence is crucial as it enables the buyer to learn about defects before closing a sale. Additionally, in the event of future legal disputes, it provides evidence that the buyer fulfilled their responsibilities and identifies any third parties who may be liable.

Laws Pertaining to Failure to Disclose

In New York, two primary laws protect buyers from undisclosed defects: New York State Law § 349 and The Property Condition Disclosure Act (PCDA).

Consumer Protection From Deceptive Acts

New York’s General Business Law (GBL) § 349, also known as the Deceptive Acts and Practices Law, protects consumers from misleading business practices. This could include, for example, a seller intentionally concealing a significant defect in a property or making a false representation of the property’s condition.

In real estate transactions, this law can provide a strong legal recourse for buyers who discover undisclosed defects after purchasing a property.

If a seller intentionally conceals a defect or falsely represents the property, they may be held liable under GBL § 349. This could result in the seller being required to compensate the buyer for losses they have incurred due to the undisclosed defect.

The Property Condition Disclosure Act (PCDA)

The Property Condition Disclosure Act (PCDA) requires sellers to provide a detailed disclosure statement about the property condition. This includes information about structural integrity, environmental hazards, utilities, and other material defects.

This act ensures transparency in real estate transactions, protecting the buyer from purchasing a property with undisclosed defects.

Failure to provide this disclosure or false information can result in the seller being held liable for the buyer’s damages, and the buyer may be entitled to compensation.

Claims Against Sellers

Buyers who purchase a property and later discover a seller’s failure to disclose home defects may have a claim against the seller.

Sellers are the primary source of information about the property and can sometimes be held liable for these issues. This could be based on fraud, breach of contract, or violation of consumer protection laws.

It’s also worth noting that the seller’s liability can extend beyond the immediate financial impact of repairing the defect. If the property’s value is significantly reduced due to the defect, the seller could be held responsible for this depreciation.

Claims Against Property Inspectors

Property inspectors play a key role in real estate transactions, providing a detailed home inspection report of a property’s condition. The information they provide can influence a buyer’s decision to purchase a property and the price they are willing to pay.

Yet, suppose an inspector fails to identify a significant defect that should have been reasonably discovered during the inspection. In that case, buyers may have a claim against them for negligence or breach of contract. These damages can include the cost of repairs, a decrease in the property’s value, and other related expenses.

It’s important to note that not all defects will necessarily give rise to a claim against a certified home inspector. They are not typically responsible for defects that are hidden or that become evident only after the inspection.

Claims Against Real Estate Brokers

Real estate brokers have a fiduciary duty to their clients. This means they are legally obligated to act in the buyers’ best interest throughout the transaction. If a broker fails to disclose known defects or misrepresents the property condition, they may be liable for any damages buyers incur.

The nature and extent of a broker’s liability can vary depending on the case, including their level of involvement in the transaction and their knowledge of the property’s condition.

Our attorneys at Richman Law Firm PLLC are well-versed in real estate law and can provide aggressive representation if a real estate broker has misled you. We investigate your claim, gather evidence, and work tirelessly to hold the responsible parties accountable.

Types of Defects Sellers and Brokers Must Disclose

There are certain defects that sellers and brokers are legally required to disclose to potential buyers. These typically include material defects that could affect the value or desirability of the property, as well as latent defects that may not be immediately evident but could cause problems down the line.

Material Defects

Material defects are issues that could impact the value of the property or its safety. These might include structural problems such as foundation cracks, roof leaks, or issues with major systems like plumbing or electrical wiring.

Latent Defects

Latent defects are hidden problems that may not be readily noticed during a routine inspection but could cause damage or risk the occupants’ safety later. These might include major issues like mold, asbestos, or termite infestation.

Preventing Undisclosed Defects Before Closing

Property defects can range from minor cosmetic issues to severe structural problems. Below are some common property defects that sellers, brokers, and inspectors often fail to disclose, and which can help buyers avoid future hidden issues if spotted early.

Structural Defects

Check for issues within the core structures of the property, such as the foundation, roof, and walls. Cracks in the foundation, leaky roofs, and unstable walls could be signs of further defects that could impact the safety and stability of a property.

System Defects

Certify that system inspections include plumbing, electrical, heating, and cooling systems. Faulty wiring, leaky pipes, and inefficient HVAC systems can be a sign of a future system failure that could hinder the functionality of a property. Defects in these areas can also lead to water damage, fire hazards, or other more serious issues.

Environmental Hazards

Not all inspection contracts verify the presence of asbestos, radon gas, lead paint, or pests like termite infestations. However, these could not only be a risk to health and safety, but they could also considerably drop the value of a property. Additionally, mold signs indicate something hazardous might have happened to the property.

Building code violations

Building code violations are another defect that can impact a property’s value and safety. These violations occur when a property doesn’t meet local or state building codes’ safety, health, or construction standards.

While some building code violations are obvious, others may not be easily identifiable during a routine inspection. For instance, the seller’s real estate agent might overlook verifying whether the seller has complied with all required city audits or routine building inspections.

This oversight can result in the buyer facing unexpected fines and legal complications due to unresolved code violations. Buyers must ensure that all necessary inspections and audits have been completed and passed to avoid these potential issues.

Next Steps After Discovering Property Defects

As a general rule, no homeowner likes to discover hidden or undisclosed home defects that could affect their property value. However, you can take steps to protect your rights and a potential claim.

  1. Document the defect: Take photographs, make notes, and gather relevant documentation.
  2. Contact a professional: Have the defect assessed by a professional to understand its extent and potential repair cost.
  3. Consult with an attorney: Seek legal advice to increase your chances of reaching fair compensation.

Statute of Limitations

In New York, the statute of limitations for bringing a claim against a seller for failure to disclose property defects is typically three years from the date of the purchase. However, this timeline may vary depending on the nature of the claim.

For example, if the claim is based on fraud, the statute of limitations may be extended to six years from the date the fraud was discovered or could have been discovered with reasonable diligence.

In the case of a claim against a property inspector or a real estate broker, the statute of limitations could be different. Consult an attorney as soon as possible to understand the timeline that applies to your case.

Contact Us for a Free Consultation

If you’ve discovered undisclosed home defects in your property and believe you have a valid claim against the seller, property inspector, or real estate broker, don’t hesitate to reach out to Richman Law Firm PLLC.

As a leading NYC law firm with a proven track record in real estate litigation, we have the knowledge and experience to handle cases involving undisclosed property defects.

We understand the intricacies of New York’s real estate laws and are well-versed in the strategies needed to successfully pursue claims against sellers, property inspectors, and real estate brokers. Contact us today for a free consultation.

FAQ

What are undisclosed property defects?

Undisclosed property defects are significant issues with a property that the seller fails to share with the buyer before the sale. These can be structural problems like foundation issues or roof damage to environmental hazards such as mold or asbestos. In New York, sellers are obligated to disclose known material defects that could affect the property’s value or the buyer’s decision to purchase. Failing to disclose such defects can lead to legal action against the seller.

How can I protect myself against property defects?

To protect yourself against property defects:

  • Hire a professional home inspector to examine the property.
  • Review the seller’s property disclosure statement carefully.
  • Ask specific questions about the property’s condition and history.
  • Include contingency clauses in your purchase agreement.
  • Consider purchasing title insurance to protect against hidden defects.
  • If possible, speak with neighbors about any known issues in the area.

Remember, while these steps can help, they don’t guarantee you’ll uncover every potential defect. If you discover undisclosed defects after purchase, consult a real estate attorney to understand your legal options.

What does “buyer beware” mean?

The principle of “buyer beware” traditionally placed the burden on the buyer to discover any defects in a property before purchase. However, New York law now provides more protection for buyers. While buyers are still expected to exercise due diligence, sellers now have a legal obligation to disclose known material defects.

Can the real estate agent be at fault for not disclosing defects before purchase?

Yes, agents can be liable if they fail to disclose property defects they knew or should have known, especially in cases where a buyer is making a significant investment. However, agents aren’t responsible for hidden defects they couldn’t reasonably discover. If you need assistance determining liability, contact Scott Richman, your NYC undisclosed property defects attorney.

Schedule a Free Consultation

Primary Contact Form
SCOTT B. RICHMAN, ESQ.

Managing Member & Founder

5.0
on Avvo

Mr. Richman is the Managing Member and Founder of Richman Law Firm PLLC. In his role as Managing Member, Mr. Richman oversees the day-to-day operations of the firm and handles the litigation of the most complex legal matters across a vast array of practice areas and disciplines.

Read What Our Clients Say About Us

Client Testimonials

    Scott Richman was hands down the best attorney we have ever had. He helped our company solve a tricky and challenging problem with speed, efficiency and professionalism. His knowledge and attention to detail go well beyond this 5 star rating. He is exceptional at what he does and I would highly recommend him.

    Scott of Richman Law is fantastic. Communicative, diligent, and reliable. He went above and beyond to ensure we not only received what we deserved, but more. If you’re looking for a fantastic lawyer, you’ve found one in Scott!

    Scott is a phenomenal lawyer. He came through for us when we were in desperate need of help. Scott always got back to us quickly for any questions we had. Highly recommend and would no doubt use his services again if needed.

    Scott proved to be an exceptional attorney, navigating my case with remarkable swiftness and unwavering diligence. In addition, Danielle exuded both warmth and professionalism, further enhancing my overall experience. I wholeheartedly recommend.